Tips for Contesting Unemployment Benefits

By Paul Edwards & Jennie McLaughlin, J.D.

What should you do when an employee resigns but later changes their story in an attempt to receive unemployment benefits? We get questions about this quite often. The employee resigns because they are moving, got a new job, want to go back to school, or didn’t think it was a good fit – or maybe they didn’t even give a reason for resignation. When this happens, you should definitely dispute the unemployment eligibility, if for no other reason than to clear up the record as to why the employee stopped working at your practice.

When an employee resigns, generally the only way that the employee will be eligible for unemployment is if it was a “constructive discharge.” Meaning, circumstances were so unbearable that the employee had no reasonable choice but to resign. An obvious example of a constructive discharge would be if the employee was subjected to ongoing harassment in the workplace and nothing was being done about it. In a situation of that sort, the employee shouldn’t have to put up with that unlawful behavior, and therefore it’s reasonable to resign and unemployment benefits may be available.

Imagine that the employee tells unemployment that she quit because the doctors were disrespectful to her and it was not a comfortable working environment. If you don’t dispute it, and the employee tries going even further and files a discrimination complaint, you can count on the employee’s attorney using the record from the unemployment hearing to show that the practice did not bother to dispute what the employee was claiming. This can certainly make it look like the practice was in the wrong, and that it was a constructive discharge. That fuels the discrimination complaint, and does not put the practice in a good light for the judge or jury.

Knowing that you should fight the unemployment eligibility, how do you go about doing that? At unemployment hearings, the only real issue is the reason for separation from employment. The unemployment office does not make rulings about other matters – although they might point the disgruntled employee in the right direction so that she can pursue another claim, which is another reason to be there to share your side of the story.

While at the hearing, or in a written response to the benefits application, don’t get caught up in details of disputing everything the employee says. A lot of he-said she-said back and forth is hard for the unemployment judge to follow, and the judges don’t like to get caught up in that. The more on point and clear the employer is, generally the more success the employer is likely to have.

If the employee is holding fast to a story involving the practice doing something wrong, you should simply explain that the employee never brought that to your attention, and that no one is aware of what she is saying being true. If you have policies asking employees to report workplace issues to you, and promising that the employer won’t retaliate in response, you should bring a copy of those policies as well. This way, you can show that if the employee had actual concerns, she could have and should have brought them to your attention. That helps call the employee’s claims into question, and makes it easier for the unemployment office to deny benefits.

(Note that all employees should have received a copy of your employee handbook, containing those policies, and signed their acknowledgment upon hire and whenever updates are made. If you haven’t followed these steps, or if your handbook doesn’t contain policies stipulating that employees must report their concerns and can do so safely, please give CEDR a call – we can help.)

Your Best Response to Employee Resignation: A Separation Letter and an Exit Interview Form

Whether you are responding to the unemployment claim by mail or attending a hearing, you want to provide documentation of the employee’s departure. Whenever an employee separates from employment – by termination, layoff, or resignation – the practice should be drafting a separation from employment letter and giving it to the departing employee. This letter should very briefly state the date and reason for the separation. It’s usually worthwhile to write your own confirmation of resignation letter rather than pushing the employee to write one. That way, the practice has control over how the resignation is initially framed in writing.

With this letter, you will want to enclose an exit interview form and a self-addressed stamped envelope, inviting the employee to send feedback to you. This packet of material ensures that you have documentation of the reason for leaving. If the employee doesn’t send back the exit interview form disputing the reason, it can go further toward establishing that what is stated in the letter is correct.

About The Author

Paul Edwards has over 25 years’ experience as a manager and owner. As CEO and Co-Founder of CEDR HR Solutions, Paul is an expert in human resources. His employment litigation avoidance techniques and customized employee handbooks have helped hundreds of medical offices in all 50 states successfully solve employee issues. He is also a featured writer for various medical publications.

49 comments

  1. NOTE: Aforementioned side-effects are two of the multifarious complications associated with consumption of http://canadianpharmacywalmart.com/ 24 hour pharmacy tablets. These side effects can be serene to smooth dangerous (in rare cases). Any mould of strength changes should be informed to the doctor canada pharmacy and if complications are severe bellow for predicament medical aid unit.

  2. acheter chaussure puma france pas cher
    air max nike pour femme
    lacoste l.ight femme
    timberland femme botte haute noir
    nike blazer area 72
    converse slim rot
    hermes arceau chronograph replica
    histoire de mizuno
    destockage air max pas cher
    sweat lacoste bleu
    ecco tour golf hybrid
    maillot bikini femme
    chaussures supra moins cher
    nike air force 1 white
    hermes picotin prezzo
    asics tennis soldes
    test asics metarun
    nike blazer mid vintage pas cher
    boutique abercrombie de paris
    converse all star petit prix
    converse 1970s collection
    asics lifestyle femme
    nike air max 24-7 pas cher
    manteau abercrombie and fitch homme
    mizuno wave prophecy 6
    studded converse rare satin rainbow
    converse en cuir argent
    taille short under armour
    emploi herm?s luxe
    basket gucci a vendre
    manteau en laine ralph lauren
    air force 1 2016
    sac birkin 35cm herm?s occasion
    spartoo new balance s410
    bonnet ralph lauren enfant
    basket nike air max bw pas cher
    air max 90 zielono czarne
    nike free sb bleu
    jonc hermes email
    converse first star 19
    converse pointure 5 et demi
    mizuno inspire 11 avis
    coffret parfum burberry the beat
    sous pull lacoste
    sac converse a roulette
    short sleeve ralph lauren button up
    veste legere lacoste
    napapijri points de vente bruxelles
    converse basses turquoise
    air jordan femme pas cher
    adidas tubular grey
    bikini vente en gros
    sac longchamp bleu graphite
    forum abercrombie
    cabat bottega veneta
    new balance running camp
    converse 70s chuck taylor
    magasin air max a paris
    sautoir hermes corne
    promo ralph lauren homme
    pas cher air max ltd hommes
    new balance prix en magasin
    dior sac femme solde
    soldes puma speed cat
    lancel dalichic solde
    air max 1 87 pas cher
    nike sb o supra
    doudoune abercrombie and fitch homme
    burberry brit pour homme avis
    u410 new balance burgundy
    hermes occasion bordeaux
    adidas lightster cush
    vans pas cher montreal
    sweatpants abercrombie soldes
    cios hermes 224
    serie mizuno
    lacoste destock
    taille asics gel lyte
    giuseppe zanotti homme occasion
    slip de bain homme bikini
    pull lacoste amazon
    converse hiver garcon
    longchamp planetes 2605
    achat bikini bresilien
    air jordan t shirts
    abercrombie hollister boutique france
    ralph lauren quick dry swim shorts
    running new balance 880v2
    hermes montres d’occasion
    boutique hermes aix en provence
    adidas kanadia 7 tr avis
    air jordan 5 taille 40
    nike air max 1 original
    amazon fr fitflop
    brit burberry perfume review
    balenciaga siege france
    adidas pure boost 2m
    marque bikini bar
    fendi 2 jours petite
    michael kors montre zalando
    kelly d’hermes d’occasion
    fake air max 90 independence day
    puma homme femme
    boutique sac dior vintage paris en ligne
    survetement adidas fille 3 ans
    nike air force junior el corte ingles
    lacoste pour homme
    obama air force one
    parfum ralph lauren 125ml
    quan jean giay converse
    nike blazer femme daim
    new balance minimus 10 trail leather
    air force 3
    chanel egoiste platinum test
    lacoste solde
    napapijri new collection
    chaussure ferragamo en ligne france
    collection hermes argent
    personnaliser c’est air max
    lacet timberland bleu
    nike air max pas cher 2012
    adidas group recrutement
    new balance bordeaux u420 homme
    nike free run 4.0 flyknit femme
    asics gel noosa tri 10
    sac voyage gucci prix
    terre hermes opinioni
    boots zippees prada
    sac michael kors marron
    nike blazer taille 35 pas cher
    nike air jordan 3 crimson
    nike air jordan spizike mens basketball shoes
    nike free sb noir
    skechers chaussure homme prix
    acheter nike air max one
    sac longchamp en solde pas cher
    chaussures ralph lauren sarenza
    nike noir air force
    air max de taille 39
    prix d’un sac prada
    chaussure air max femme
    ouverture chaussure under armour bruxelles
    chaussure new balance vintage
    ecco i cento film italiani da salvare
    arsenik lacoste
    air max 1 original colorway
    monture lunette de vue ray ban
    comment taille les asics
    givenchy usine
    nike shox blanc
    survetement lacoste blanc et noir
    basket new balance bruxelles
    converse all star camouflage
    asics noir et vert
    nike air max ltd 2 marron pas cher
    ralph lauren chemise homme slim fit
    playlist hollister 2012
    magasin lacoste nimes
    coffret layette ralph lauren
    sennheiser adidas sport ocx 685i
    asics promo
    gucci by gucci zapach
    reebok 15
    air max 90 gs pas cher
    vetement de marque ralph lauren pas cher
    boutique chanel bijoux paris
    prix ceinture dior femme
    jean abercrombie
    mizuno wave precision taille 43
    chaussures route new balance chaussure
    nike air max femme mode
    ralph lauren khaki pants
    air jordan 5 images
    michael kors handbags in france
    baskets lacoste enfant
    chaussures femmes chanel pas cher
    nike air max classic aus holland
    new balance femme moins cher
    la redoute adidas superstar
    hollister france rouen
    vente aux encheres gucci luxembourg
    sac serviette homme longchamps
    sonoya mizuno boyfriend
    basket new balance 36
    ballerine ferragamo taille
    air max one femme pas cher
    air max 90 chez courir
    chaussure lacoste homme foot locker
    bikini tests 1946
    plo ralph lauren
    basket air max one femme
    sacoche bandouliere homme lacoste
    lancel bb en jean
    ultra chanel joaillerie
    veste abercrombie homme shoppy discount
    hollister playlist labor day 2013
    chateau lacoste aix
    hermes george v
    nike blazer 2016
    acheter ensemble ralph lauren
    sac 48h converse all star
    jogging converse femme
    air max classic bw nike id
    club de golf mizuno jpx ez
    solde lancel adjani
    adidas originals zx flux print
    piece detachee rowenta air force extreme
    gucci mane be my girl
    balenciaga first shoulder strap length
    converse chucks 1g350 simply taupe ox
    asics gel lyte v nightshade navy
    kazunori mizuno
    sacs hermes
    acheter air max 90 jacquard
    napapijri skidoo prix
    ceinture gucci garantie
    acheter ceinture burberry
    magasin de converse a grenoble
    sur le chemin des sens lieu-dit lacoste 24210 azerat
    sac sport lacoste
    code reduction ferragamo
    bonnes nouvelles bertrand lacoste
    derbies lacoste
    asics gel fujiendurance plasmaguard
    prada ballerine 2015
    sac longchamp 4×4 occasion
    saucony chaussure boutique en ligne
    hollister playlist winter 2009
    veste homme napapijri skidoo noir 3xl
    converse light trainers
    survetement adidas homme xxl
    mizuno wave rider osaka femme
    basket nike air force 1 suede
    new balance trail 573v2
    converse montant au genou
    hollister playlist keep me dancing
    nike free run femme verte
    new balance 420 prix
    ralph lauren short bain
    lancel l adjani prix
    nike free trainer 3.0
    asics dor?
    new balance france prix
    ralph lauren arctic parka
    taille chaussures ferragamo
    miu miu soldes ?t? 2017
    magasins chaussure timberland rivoli
    rue ernest lacoste
    portefeuille lancel compagnon
    sac banane lacoste
    mizuno enigma wave 5
    polos ralph lauren femme pas cher
    black friday mizuno
    mizuno steam 3
    sac converse bowling accessoires
    adidas ax2 gore-tex m
    lancel sacoche homme
    site timberland chaussure boutique
    veste lacoste occasion
    mizuno wave rider 16 avis
    doudoune ralph lauren denim & supply femme
    bottines femme timberland noir
    t shirt lacoste noir
    nike air max pas cher 87
    vintage jacket adidas
    coudre une veste style chanel
    soldes ballerine ferragamo pas cher
    chanel maquillage blush
    vans solde femme
    marque hollister date de fondation
    air max fille taille 30
    selma michael kors large
    montre michael kors femme strass
    abercrombie paris champs elys?es horaires
    lacoste bomber
    nike free run blanche et noir
    usine ralph lauren
    abercrombie vente en ligne belgique
    napapijri lyon 69002
    chaussure timberland marcel
    ballerine ferragamo soldes homme
    lacoste 16 ans
    collection chanel 2015
    vrai ou fausse converse
    vans chaussure bateau
    new balance coupon august 2015
    new balance 45 numara
    mizuno inspire 12 w
    hermes heure h pret
    air force 1 ultraforce
    bonnet napapijri la redoute
    hollister et abercrombie site officiel
    chanel lunettes de soleil 2015
    magasin converse bordeaux lac
    sweat capuche homme lacoste
    chaussures prada vente en ligne
    air max classic online bestellen
    voyage d hermes
    pour napapijri
    polo by ralph lauren spain
    ralph lauren polo norway
    converse slim venezuela
    christian louboutin en ligne
    tenis nike estilo supra
    commande internet hollister avis
    converse metallica
    cartable converse fille
    vente privee lunette oakley
    lacoste market
    boutique lancel aeroport de paris
    nike air jordan 13 xiii air force one fusion
    tee shirt lacoste blanc
    asics miami
    nike air max classic kinderschuhe
    nike free run pas cher fille
    pantalon asics
    new balance pas cher pour fille
    converse turquie
    boutique timberland bruxelles
    sac longchamp gloucester occasion
    hollister und abercrombie das gleiche
    air jordan spizike info
    polo lacoste taille 8
    porte monnaie lacoste femme
    ralph lauren home market share
    adidas nationalit?
    montre michael kors mk8184
    air jordan femme marseille
    adidas superstar reflechissante
    sac longchamp roseau noir solde
    vans pas ch?re homme
    tee shirt hollister femme prix
    converse baskets one star lo pro mid
    taille gazelle adidas
    mizuno wave rider 16m
    nike air max 90 zappos
    magasin abercrombie irlande
    sac longchamp pliable en soldes
    polo ralph lauren frankfurt
    j cole reebok
    chaussures mbt speed 17m
    jean ralph lauren
    montre chanel j12 avec diamant
    nike shox blue
    tong hollister femme
    taille chaussure mizuno
    comment reconnaitre une vraie paire d air max
    nike supra
    go sport survetement adidas
    publicit? lacoste
    Related Articles

  3. obama insurance individual insurance
    http://viagracouponscodes.com/#oknkh.html
    viagra savings offer care health insurance plan
    pfizer viagra coupon
    face stroke test
    http://www.viagracouponscodes.com/ viagra savings
    first aid test

  4. pilule generic viagra

    http://viagragenonline.com/ – cheap viagra

    viagra

    cheapest viagra 10mg

  5. msc medical education heat and fatigue
    http://viagrasamplescoupon.com/#sjbnm.html
    viagra coupons signs of a sunstroke
    viagra sample
    signs of a std in a woman
    http://www.viagrasamplescoupon.com/ viagra samples
    std in men signs and symptoms

  6. Hello! Online Pharmacies excellent site.

  7. testicular pain std quote health insurance
    http://canadianpharmacywalmart.com/#vsbyc.html
    online pharmacy canada health coverage insurance
    canadian pharmacy
    temporary health insurance

  8. Just about any long lasting mortgage that may be extended compared to Four years is based on relationship yields. They can insert a drywall screw with the sub floor and in to the flooring to stop the squeak.”The Rangers probably have the best shot at obtaining him,” the GM said. Cheap NFL Jerseys China. The mini chenille bear brings Floral bar soap and other bath accessories, floral potpourri, and a pillar candle in a white gloss gift box with pink and purple tissue paper,Cheap NHL Jerseys China, and tied up with a pink satin ribbon.1.Article From Article Directory DatabaseRangers Wont Rule Out Cruz At Right PriceRealGM WiretapNelson Cruz remains on the market as Opening Day approaches.”The Rangers probably have the best shot at obtaining him,” the GM said. Repaired period charges like most long term mortgages depend on connection promotes. Within Canada, interest rates usually are managed because of the Federal Reserve. Excited to this cause, below are some tips to get Clash of Clans Free Gems. This gift box is also a great birthday or get well gift for kids.If the new home is in a suburban region located next to undeveloped or thickly wooded land, think of investing in a tall wooden or chainlink fence round the perimeter of your backyard.Wholesale NHL Jerseys Cheap.Visit my site:http://www.wholesalejerseyscheapnfl.us.com/

  9. order viagra online india
    generic viagra cost
    buy viagra from china
    generic viagra prices
    viagra buy online generic

  10. max payday loan
    payday loans online
    bad credit catalogues
    payday advance loans
    bayside payday loans

  11. where can i buy the viagra
    viagra
    viagra for sale online
    viagra for men
    buy viagra vietnam

  12. levitra on sale
    levitra
    buy levitra online ireland
    vardenafil 20mg
    levitra buy no prescription

  13. buy cialis online with a prescription
    cialis 20mg pricing
    buy cialis professional cheap
    cialis 20 mg price
    buy cialis from usa

  14. Hi there! reputable online pharmacies beneficial internet site.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.